IMAGE/CON/TEXT
Documentary practices between journalism, art and activism
What is the relationship of image and text? Through what strategies do texts find their way into images, and what kind of textuality do these images reveal? To what extent are the verbal and the visual interwoven in discourse and narrative? The textuality of photography and the associated notion that images can be read as texts has been a well-established concept in both practice and theory since the 1970s and 1980s. However, current discourses on documentary increasingly express an understanding that seeks to conceptualise the relationship between visual and verbal media as a heterogeneous field of representational practices. Building on the interweaving of representation and discourse and the intertwining of visual and verbal experience, as described by W.J.T. Mitchell, amongst others, they understand the image–text relationship as one in which the spheres of the readable and the visible have always inevitably intermingled. By combining various forms of documentation and testimony, current projects are therefore increasingly focusing on image-text combinations and their complementary nature. In doing so, they recognise that no document, no testimony, can in itself provide direct evidence, but always entails the possibility of fiction. Moving beyond the demand for unambiguous visual and textual clarity, they address their own contextuality as a prerequisite for meaning and impact. For them, meaning arises within every publication context, with every reception, and through every mode of reading and viewing; it is not fixed but fluid, circulating and migrating.
BOOK
– image/con/text
In 2020, the publication ‘image/con/text. Documentary Practices between Journalism, Art and Activism’ was published. The central question was: How can, and how should, one give images impact? The search for new narrative forms in the fields of photojournalism and documentary photography – forms that broaden our perspective beyond the boundaries of the conventional understanding of the documentary form – was a key driving force behind the previous [IMAGE MATTERS] publication ‘Images in Conflict / Bilder im Konflikt’. The question of the possibilities of the documentary form and the development of visual narratives that subvert stereotypes and traditional viewing habits is further explored in the volume ‘image/con/text’: the contributions focus in particular on the textuality and contextuality of documentary practices and the exploration of their boundaries – specifically, the relationship between art, documentation and journalism.
Read more
In ‘Photography Against the Grain’ (1984), Allan Sekula wrote: ‘Against the photoessayistic promise of “life” caught by the camera, I sought to work from within a world already replete with signs.’ Treating photographs as autonomous, self-explanatory windows on the world does justice neither to the complexity of reality nor to the intricacy of our systems of representation. Given that any mode – whether photographic or text-based – is liable to suffer intrinsic inadequacies, documentary practice tends to be most productive where multiple forms of representation synergise. ‘image/con/text’ builds on this idea of complementarity. Journalistic images in particular utilise – and require – context to convey meaning. Often this means captions. But accompanying images and/or documents can also accomplish the same effect. As well as revealing the complex relationships between visual and verbal mediatisations, this also creates a layering and nesting of meaning that is increasingly employed by documentary storytellers to narrate and contextualise hidden stories.
‘image/con/text’ examines image/text relations in notable contemporary and historical projects, focussing particularly on the medium of the photobook, but also encompassing film, multimedia and the comic genre. The strategies examined bring together journalistic, artistic and activist positions, weaving fact and fiction to reveal the constellations of power in the process of representation. Photographic narrators are increasingly employing the possibilities of deliberately generated context, not least to expand the scope of the narratable.
The book was published in 2020 by Reimer Verlag, Berlin, and simultaneously by arthistoricum as an open-access publication available for free download.
→ Table of contents
→ Book launch video
Edited by Karen Fromm, Sophia Greiff, Malte Radtki and Anna Stemmler
Reimer Verlag, Berlin 2020, with texts in German and English
352 pages, 168 illustrations
With a variety of voices and practices, ‘image/con/text. Documentary Practices Between Journalism, Art and Activism’ adds to the so much needed discourse on today’s documentary photography. During the symposium, which served as the ground work for this publication, it became once more apparent how important it is to be aware of one’s perspective and position as documentary photographer.
– Iris Sikking – Curator, lecturer and author specialising in photography, film and digital art
Book Launch
As ‘image/con/text. Documentary Practices between Journalism, Art and Activism’ was published in autumn 2020 during the coronavirus pandemic, the [IMAGE MATTERS] team organised an online book launch. Moderated by Steffen Siegel, Karen Fromm and Susanne von Falkenhausen discussed with Edmund Clark and Martha Rosler the question of how the political might be brought back into the documentary – or to what extent activist, artistic and journalistic perspectives overlap in documentary practices. Can the deliberate creation of contexts for representing a complex world do greater justice to that world?
Biographies and abstracts
Articles
SYMPOSIUM
– image/con/text
The symposium ‘image/con/text: Complementary Testimonies in Documentary Discourse’, held on 29–30 October 2019, focused on recent works that explicitly aim to blend the realms of the readable and the visible. Has the relationship between image and text in documentary discourse actually changed over the last 10 years? Moving beyond the idea of a comparison of image-based and text-based media, the symposium will examine the entirety and complexity of the relationships of image and text in projects particularly from the area of the photobook, but also in multimedia, film, comic and the narrative forms of the archive. The main focus of attention here will be the question of what consequences follow from the ‘suturing of image and text’ with respect to concepts of testimony and documentarism. Can the idea of the complementarity of testimonies navigate the gulf between positions of absolutised truth and relativism?
Following Images in Conflict, this was the second symposium organised by the [IMAGE MATTERS] discourse platform, which was launched by the Visual Journalism and Documentary Photography degree programme to foster dialogue between issues arising from photographic practice and discourses in image and photography theory, as well as visual and cultural studies.
Speakers
Videos
Day 1 – Tuesday 29 October 2019
Day 2 – Wednesday 30 October 2019
Press reviews
of image/con/text
BOOK
Deutschlandfunk Kultur / Kompressor:
Karen Fromm in conversation with Massimo Maio
Foto \ Kunst \ Theorie. Der Sprengel FOTO-Blog:
Inka Schube: Auf der Suche nach neuen dokumentarischen Praktiken
Podcast at the LUMIX Festival 2020:
‘Neue Perspektiven des Dokumentarischen’: the [IMAGE MATTERS] team in conversation with Jan Nasemann